A Fair-Sharing Challenge: Divide 24 Kits Between Three Clubs
Is eight kits per club fair if one club has twice as many members?
Set up the activity
Give three pretend clubs membership cards showing four, eight and twelve children. Use 24 counters as kits. First divide the counters equally between clubs. Next try giving one kit to each child. Describe whose share you are comparing before saying the word equal.
Compare the allocation rules
| Club | Members | Equal per club | One per member |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 4 | 8 | 4 |
| B | 8 | 8 | 8 |
| C | 12 | 8 | 12 |
Eight kits per club looks balanced across the three club labels. Look inside the clubs, though. A can give each member two kits, B one kit and C cannot give every member one. A per-child rule allocates four, eight and twelve. Both plans use 24 kits and apply different criteria.
Change one condition
There are now only 18 kits. Proportional shares are three, six and nine. The rates match at three kits for every four members. That still leaves individual children without a kit if kits must stay whole. Discuss how a rotation could share access over several meetings.
Try it before revealing the answers
Why doesn't equal allocation between clubs guarantee equal allocation per member?
Check your reasoning
The clubs have different membership counts. Divide each club's allocation by its own membership to compare rates.
If the clubs receive three, six and nine kits, which has the largest number of members without a kit today?
Check your reasoning
Club C has three without one. A has one and B has two if each kit goes to a different member.
Can arithmetic alone decide which need should come first?
Check your reasoning
It can show who receives what under each rule. Choosing priorities requires an agreed purpose and information about needs.
A second round
Ask each team to propose an allocation rule before moving the counters. Another team checks the arithmetic and describes one person or club that the rule serves well. Change the supply and test whether the rule can still be applied.
When to use this activity
The United Nations calendar lists International Human Solidarity Day on 20 December 2026. This BananaLearn classroom activity uses original examples for families and teachers.
United Nations calendar for December 2026